Heavenly Sweets Wedding Cakes

I can't begin to describe how beautiful and delicious our daughter's wedding cake was! She had a clear vision of how she wanted her cake to look and Tanya at Heavenly Sweets more than delivered. Our guests remarked on how moist and tasty the cake was, many expressed they wished they could have had another piece! We found Heavenly Sweets easy to work with, the cake delivery went off without a hitch, all in all an outstanding experience!

When we first moved to Indianapolis a decade ago we needed a birthday cake for our daughter's 13th birthday. My wife's co-worker had just gotten married and said the cake they got for their wedding from Heavenly Sweets was the best he'd ever eaten. So we tried it. It was HUGE hit. So huge, that Ohio family members still sometimes ask us to bring the cake for family parties.

We just finished eating a cake we got for the same daughter's 23rd birthday and all we could talk about was how much we loved Heavenly Sweets. They also have amazing cupcakes so sometimes we get an assortment of those for special occasions, which gives a variety of options for people. It's about a 20 minute drive for us and it is so worth it. Be warned that you get what you pay for. They are on the more expensive side. But the quality justifies the cost. I've literally never had a better cake anywhere.

I've been buying the same cake for years from Heavenly Sweets (butter cream with caramel) and it has been consistently amazing. Without a doubt it is the best cake I've had anywhere. I'd highly recommend getting a birthday or wedding cake from HS. You don't be disappointed.

Heavenly Sweet Cakes are the best we have ever had! Used them for our parents 50th wedding anniversary & recently for our daughters wedding! One guest said she doesn't eat white cake but loved this one! Not only do their cakes taste amazing but they are beautifully decorated too!

Beautiful, delicious cake! Heavenly Sweets did the cake for our wedding, and not only was it beautiful, it was fresh, moist, and delicious! I can't tell you how many guests asked us where we got our cake - they absolutely LOVED it! A lot of times when I've had cake at weddings, it looks pretty, but doesn't always taste the best. But this was not the case with Heavenly Sweets - it was perfect! Just can't say enough about how good it was!

We LOVE Heavenly Sweets! She did our wedding cake which was amazing and logistically everything worked our perfectly. We saved the top cake level in the freezer for our one year anniversary and we were pleasantly surprised that it still tasted amazing! Recently ordered a mother's day cake and, as usual, it was delicious. Highly recommend!

Tanya did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake. The most beautiful cake, and the most delicious-tasting cake. I'm a person that hates frosting too, and her frosting is delicious! I will say if you are looking for a custom cake for another occasion, I would be weary. We had issues with color matching and design for a birthday cake. Still delicious though!

We chose Heavenly Sweets because it was recommended to us by someone who had used them before, and we are so glad we did. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and so delicious. Guests are still raving about how good it was! In addition to being a great cake in general, Tanya was a joy to work with. When we needed to change venues due to downsizing our event, it was an easy change and we knew we were in good hands. Thank you for making our day that much more special with the perfect cake!

I can't say enough great things about Tanya and Heavenly Sweets! She was a dream to work with and made the process of cake tasting and designing our wedding cake so much fun. I absolutely loved how beautiful and elegant my cake looked and it tasted AMAZING. Our guests raved about how wonderful the cake was and the balance of the flavors. Highly recommend Tanya!

Love this place! We had our wedding cake made here. Not only beautiful but honestly one of the best tasting cakes we've ever had. They always have a wide selection of cupcakes available to take home as well. Singles, dbls, quads or buy 11 and get one free! You won't be disappointed!