Shaffer's Cake and Candy Supplies has been a staple in the community for years. What started out as Milloway's, a small cake business out of Carolyn Milloway's kitchen, gradually became what we know today as Shaffer's. While in the Cake business Carolyn decided to venture into chocolate making. When her customers seen what she was doing they wanted to learn also.

Carolyn would travel over a hour away to pick up chocolate, bring it back home, weigh it out in her kitchen and sell it out of her tiny store that was one a dining room.

Update Share

Lorica VonBarnes

Apr 30, 2021

Report

I love the many different molds and cookie cutters just wish they had online ordering and delivery or curbside pickup due to my walking disability and use of a wheelie walker.

Donna Consiglio

Jan 26, 2021

Report

I just received my order that I placed online. Everything was packaged really well. The chocolate tasted excellent, best I have had. I used to live only a few blocks from the physical location but moved several years ago. It was so great to be to use the melting chocolate to make lollipops and bunnies for my family. Everyone approves! The owner is also knowledgeable, helpful, friendly, and provided me with excellent customer service.

Nan Quintrell

Dec 29, 2019

Report

I love to come here. The new owner is very pleasant, and is very knowlegable about what she sells. She has so much to consider buying. So if you're making candy, or cakes stop in here!

Victoria Martinez

Dec 29, 2019

Report

Great place to locally find cake and confection supplies. Only down side is the hours have changed again and you really have to plan your trip since availability is Tuesday to Friday.

Kim Lepley

Jun 11, 2019

Report

This place is a cake decorators dream. I felt like I died and went to heaven. Fabulous! Its a treasure in the rough! I love that I stumbled on this place, they have everything every cake decorator could ever want! Even if they don't want it!

Patricia Harris

Jun 10, 2019

Report

The store may be small but they stock so many neat and interesting items. A baker & candy maker's dream shop. And the owner is so nice and willing to make any combo of decorating sugars, jimmies etc. You have to stop in and see for yourself. Funny thing, I don't bake and still find things I need!

Jess Shoup

Apr 23, 2019

Report

This tiny, hidden store has all all sorts of candy making supplies. I was amazed at how much was available. The owner was very helpful as well and also very knowledgeable about her products. She even provided us with a recipe for a product we bought!

Glenda Fink

Dec 15, 2018

Report

The owner was very helpful and full of information. lots of parking outside since it's in a residential neighborhood. The store is very neatly kept and organized. There were so many more items and you can possibly imagine and the prices are remarkably competitive with stores like Walmart and target I will definitely be back. thank you for a wonderful first experience. I bought candle and pretzel candie molds for my upcoming halloween wedding. I can't wait to make them.

Robert Makar

Nov 15, 2018

Report

Always a pleasure visiting the shop. So many things and creative ideas there, good prices too. Also if she doesn't have what you need she will order or tell you where you can get it. How is that for service?

Dominic Scicchitano

Sep 20, 2018

Report

I Love Shaffer's Cake and Candy Supply. I go there often for all my baking needs. Lots of different Cake Decorations and cake pans to choose from. Great selection of seasonal sprinkles, and flavor extracts. Highly recommend stopping in!