Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Cakery The Cakery has been professionally enhancing weddings and events with artfully designed cakes in San Luis Obispo County and the Central Coast since 2003. The Cakery is dedicated to producing outstanding cakes from simple elegance to extravagant wedding cakes. We can duplicate any design or create an original work of art specifically tailored to your wedding theme and personality.

We only use the finest and freshest ingredients which include whole eggs, real butter and pure vanilla extract. We believe that your cake should not only look fabulous but taste just as wonderful.
Follow us
Services
At The Cakery we believe that simplicity takes the cake. We like to keep our cake flavors simple and delicious. We let the fillings make the magic happen. By changing the filling you can change the taste and feel of the entire cake. Just in case you don't want to keep it simple though, we are more than happy to help create something unique and special to you.
Because no two weddings are alike It is impossible to set up a price list or give a quote without more information about the event. Each cake has many variables. We take into account the number of servings, the complexity of design, and the addition of fondant or handmade flowers, if any. Our prices start at $8.50 per serving for buttercream cakes and $9.75 per serving for fondant cakes.
Reviews (19)
Write a Review
Mira Vista
Jun 23, 2022
Amy creates the most stunning and gorgeous cakes. You cannot go wrong with her. She is prompt and professional. Loved working with them for our first event.
G. F.
May 27, 2022
Absolutely beautiful cake and so delicious! Amy was a joy to work with - professional and accommodating. Hands down the best desserts on central coast.
Paula Hall
Apr 16, 2022
Amy made our wedding cake experience a breeze. She perfected what we envisioned and it was the best tasting cake we've ever had! Everyone was raving about how amazing it was. We will use her for our future baking needs - she's the absolute best and a true professional! xx Paula & Eric
Monique Hurley
Nov 17, 2021
Amy was so easy to work with! I was struggling with finding a baker in the area and even though she was booked with other weddings, she still managed to fit mine in. She brought my wedding cake dreams to life. She knew exactly what I wanted, and it was so elegant and classy. She was able to create little pumpkins to place on each of the cupcakes, and gold flakes on our cake.

She was able to even bake my husband Gluten Free cupcakes even though I requested it last minute! All of the flavors were absolutely amazing. I cannot thank her enough for the best cake and cupcakes we ever had!
Devin Stewart
Sep 24, 2021
Unbelievable talent and everything tastes so delicious! Amy is incredible and every dessert she creates is a 10/10!
Kelsey P.
Apr 23, 2021
Amy was a delight to work with and quick to respond. We made a last minute order (called a day before we needed it) and were SO grateful she was able to squeeze us in. We ordered the raspberry cream cheese cake for my mother's birthday! The cake was moist and delicious. And the filling, was incredible, my sister wanted a bowl of just filling. Amy will be our go to baker for future celebrations.
Amanda Holder
Feb 02, 2021
The Cakery knocks it out of the park every time! We (and our clients) absolutely LOVE working with them! Beautiful, and delicious!
Meggan C.
Dec 02, 2018
Lonielle is the BEST cake baker I have ever met! Our cake was so beautiful and tasty! I wish I had her skills. My husband and I came in for a tasting about a year before our wedding and we are not sweets people, but we could eat her cake everyday! I would NOT book anyone else. The cake was not overly sweet, it was not dry, it was simply perfection.

I would highly recommend The Cakery. I honestly would request a cake from her again for any event my husband and I are having. Lonielle, please do not change a thing! I'm sure you will be hearing from us again soon. Love Always, Meggan & Jeff PS. As soon as I have pictures, I will send them to you.
Sean R.
Feb 24, 2018
Lonielle made our wedding cake as well as our anniversary cakes. They have all been both delicious and beautiful. The artistry she delivers is second to none and has been a pleasure to work with every time. Not enough stars on here to give her. Thank you Lonielle!
Ray B.
Feb 08, 2018
Lonielle is an amazing Artist. The birthday cake was beautiful and everyone commented that it was the best birthday cake they had ever eaten. Great job! Heartily recommend.
Jamie C.
Nov 30, 2017
The cake was DELICIOUS! What more can I say? Here's a photo. It was beautiful as well. Lonielle needed very little direction or communication from me. We booked her almost a year before the wedding and we checked in once or twice. She showed up the day of the wedding with a gorgeous naked cake exactly as I described ("naked, but not too naked, you know?").

She nailed it. PS - if you love coconut go with her coconut cream frosting. I plan to order from her again just to eat that frosting - as soon as I can come up with a good excuse!
Edrienne Y.
Sep 21, 2017
Working with The Cakery was such a pleasure. Lonielle always stayed in contact, answering my MANY questions! She was so flexible with my changing guest list and made sure to accommodate the amount of cake with the amount of guests we were having. When my husband and I went to the tasting, we were so amazed at the taste of the cake! The cake designs she had were beautiful but the best part was the actual taste of the cake!

It was delicious! The cake was soft, the buttercream complimented the cake so well! The buttercream flavors weren't overbearing. I couldn't stop eating my cake! Thank you Lonielle!
Kim S.
Feb 16, 2017
Am changing my review because I believe you'll do better. Regardless of the past, I want to support local business. Good luck!
Francine L.
Dec 10, 2016
Long overdue post but I wanted to give credit where credit is due. I wrote this post on 04/25/14 but forgot to post it. Found it on my phone in the "NotePad" app. I was married on 02/22/14. My wedding cake was BEAUTIFUL! I decided to go with the Cakery after my chef recommended them. Out of all my wedding vendor appointments, this was by far my favorite.

They had a great variety to choose from. Definitely not your average choices. After tasting the many different selections, we decided to go with 2 different flavors: white cake with a raspberry marmalade and salted caramel buttercream, as well as devil's food cake with the white cake with raspberry marmalade and salted caramel cream filling was a play on peanut butter and jelly.

Since it was so different and tasted exactly like it, we thought it would be perfect for us and our guests. The devil's food cake was the other choice for obvious reasons: we wanted to cater to chocolate lovers! As far as the artistry on the cake, we chose one of their designs that was classic. We chose the Dogwoods cake. It is featured in their cake gallery online.

It is simply beautiful! 3 layers of off-white buttercream frosting, with cascading peach-colored handcrafted flowers and blue berries. It was so pretty! When I walked into my venue, they showcased the wedding cake in the center of the dance floor for all to admire as they walked to their seats. I also paid for lighting, with a pinspot on the cake which added a dramatic spotlight.

It was so worth it. I had a gelato bar so everyone was able to enjoy their cake with "ice cream"! It was perfect and everything I had hoped for. Thank you, The Cakery, for a deliciously beautiful work of art!
Ben C.
Jun 19, 2016
Everything was perfect. We worked with Lonielle on our wedding cake and cupcakes. The cake was delicious. The dessert table turned out amazing. Lonielle was a pleasure to work with. I would highly recommend anyone in need of some cake - for any reason - to reach out to Lonielle.
Laura J.
Jan 24, 2016
Lonielle is amazing! I was a destination bride and she couldn't have made the process easier. Our cake turned out exactly how I hoped and even better it tasted phenomenal. My wedding guests raved about it and some even commented how they are not usually "cake" kind of people, but they got seconds. Highly recommend The Cakery!
Renee S.
Dec 04, 2014
Lonielle is an artist of the baking kind! First and foremost, it was extremely hard to choose a cake because they're all amazing. We sampled 8 cakes all of which were different yet delicious. Once we picked the cake flavor out, we showed Lonielle our little pinterest photo of a baseball themed cake. Much like the other review on here, she made it a reality. She gave us suggestions and made everything beautiful. Our guests were RAVING about the cake, and we hardly had ANY leftover. THANK YOU!
B. R.
Oct 02, 2014
90th Birthday party. Fabulous cake. Several layers. All delicious! Everyone at the party ( people from the Bay Area and Southern Ca) wanted to know where I got it. Lonielle was professional, accommodating, flexible with changes and had some great suggestions. If you have a special event in your future, this is the place to get your cake. WARNING: Place your order early, for Lonielle get busy very quickly! Arroyo Grande customer
Jen P.
Dec 11, 2013
The Cakery is AMAZING! 1-The cake was delicious! 2- Lonielle took my little picture from Pintrest and made my cake a reality 3- When she dropped off the cake Lonielle really took the time to place the flowers and arrange the cake table so everything was beautiful (and out of harms way). She was a pleasure to work with and I can't recommend the Cakery highly enough! If you need a cake in the SLO area look no farther!